Trout Fishing

Where can I trout fish in Western New York State?

I am looking for some recommendations to hopefully do some stream or river trout fishing while traveling to Rochester, NY from Philadelphia, PA and will be passing through Binghamton along the way. Diverting my trip a little bit for the fishing portion is not an issue. I am not that familiar with western NY so any help would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks for the answers so far. Special regulations are not a problem, I will be using the fly rod.
And I will be doing catch and release with barbless hooks.

If you don't want to go out of your way and turn east toward the Catskills, then turn west toward me! Presumably, you will be travelling north on I-81. Turn west on Rte 17 or I-86 (same road). There are a number of streams with trout along the way. I am most familiar with Cayuta Creek, which you will cross at Waverly, NY. There are numerous public fishing access points to this stream from Route 34 and Route 224.

Farther west, you will be driving along the Conhocton River, which parallels the highway until I-390 turns off headed toward Rochester., along with the River, which remains accessible and fishable for several more miles.

Each of these streams has special regulation areas, meaning artificials only with non-standard creel limits.

Now I'll hand you off to someone from the Rochester area.

Find Trout Fishing On eBay Below:

Bomber BSW16AXRT H D Long A 7 8oz 6 Rainbow Trout Fishing Lure
Bomber BSW16AXRT H D Long A 7 8oz 6 Rainbow Trout Fishing Lure
$13.15
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Gold a L81
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Gold a L81
$0.10
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Green a L81
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Green a L81
$0.45
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm SilverB L81
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm SilverB L81
$0.10
NEW RAPALA SKITTER WALK SW 8 SPECKLED TROUT FISHING LURES
NEW RAPALA SKITTER WALK SW 8 SPECKLED TROUT FISHING LURES
$7.95
Boone Castana 5020 Australian Orange Fishing Lure 1 2 oz 3 1 4 Trout Snook
Boone Castana 5020 Australian Orange Fishing Lure 1 2 oz 3 1 4 Trout Snook
$10.00
Boone Castana 5020 Fire Orange Fishing Lure 1 2 oz 3 1 4 Trout Snook Redfish
Boone Castana 5020 Fire Orange Fishing Lure 1 2 oz 3 1 4 Trout Snook Redfish
$18.00
Boone Castana 5020 Orange Flo Red Saltwater Fishing Lure 1 2 oz 3 1 4 Trout
Boone Castana 5020 Orange Flo Red Saltwater Fishing Lure 1 2 oz 3 1 4 Trout
$9.00
Boone Castana 5020 Blue Saltwater Fishing Lure 1 2 oz 3 1 4 long Trout Snook
Boone Castana 5020 Blue Saltwater Fishing Lure 1 2 oz 3 1 4 long Trout Snook
$10.00
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm SilverB AL5
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm SilverB AL5
$0.25
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Green AL5
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Green AL5
$0.25
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Gold AL5
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Gold AL5
$0.25
Fishing Lures Metal Slice Spoon Tackle Salmon Tailor Trout Redfin Bass Brea
Fishing Lures Metal Slice Spoon Tackle Salmon Tailor Trout Redfin Bass Brea
$5.33
Soft Fishing Bait Frogs Lures Bionics Surface Lure for Bass Trout 12cm Green
Soft Fishing Bait Frogs Lures Bionics Surface Lure for Bass Trout 12cm Green
$1.45
2 PACKS CHATTER SHRIMP WEEDLESS 1 4 OZ RED WITH PINK FLIPPER REDFISH TROUT
2 PACKS CHATTER SHRIMP WEEDLESS 1 4 OZ RED WITH PINK FLIPPER REDFISH TROUT
$6.99
2 PACKS CHATTER SHRIMP WEEDLESS 1 4 OZ RED WITH RED FLIPPER REDFISH TROUT
2 PACKS CHATTER SHRIMP WEEDLESS 1 4 OZ RED WITH RED FLIPPER REDFISH TROUT
$6.49
RMG POLTERGEIST 50MM LURE X1 PER PACK
RMG POLTERGEIST 50MM LURE X1 PER PACK
$11.12
5pcs 14g jigheads Red Bream Bass Redfin Flathead Trout Redfin Whiting Cod Perch
5pcs 14g jigheads Red Bream Bass Redfin Flathead Trout Redfin Whiting Cod Perch
$6.86
Topwater Frog Fishing Lures Baits Bass Trout Bait Soft Bait 12cm 65g Yellow
Topwater Frog Fishing Lures Baits Bass Trout Bait Soft Bait 12cm 65g Yellow
$1.68
Topwater Frog Fishing Lures Baits Bass Trout Bait Soft Bait 47 65g Pink
Topwater Frog Fishing Lures Baits Bass Trout Bait Soft Bait 47 65g Pink
$1.68
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Green AL3
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Green AL3
$0.10
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm SilverB AL3
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm SilverB AL3
$0.30
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Gold AL3
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Gold AL3
$0.10
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Green a L91
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Green a L91
$0.10
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Gold a L91
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm Gold a L91
$0.10
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm SilverB L91
Fishing Lure Trout Barra Jacks Queenfish Kingfish Sealurer Fish 14cm SilverB L91
$0.10
2 SPECK RIGS 1 8 OZ YELLOW YELLOW SPECKLED TROUT REDFISH
2 SPECK RIGS 1 8 OZ YELLOW YELLOW SPECKLED TROUT REDFISH
$4.99
Boone Spinana 5000 Froggy Fishing Lure 1 3 oz 3 Trout Snook Redfish
Boone Spinana 5000 Froggy Fishing Lure 1 3 oz 3 Trout Snook Redfish
$9.00
Boone Spinana 5000 Gold Fishing Lure 1 3 oz 3 Trout Snook Redfish
Boone Spinana 5000 Gold Fishing Lure 1 3 oz 3 Trout Snook Redfish
$9.00
Boone Spinana 5000 Orange Flo Red Fishing Lure 1 3 oz 3 Trout Snook Redfish
Boone Spinana 5000 Orange Flo Red Fishing Lure 1 3 oz 3 Trout Snook Redfish
$9.00
Boone Spinana 5000 Australian Orange Fishing Lure 1 3 oz 3 Trout Snook Redfish
Boone Spinana 5000 Australian Orange Fishing Lure 1 3 oz 3 Trout Snook Redfish
$9.00
Boone Castana 5020 Fire Yellow Fishing Lure 1 2 oz 3 1 4 Trout Snook Redfish
Boone Castana 5020 Fire Yellow Fishing Lure 1 2 oz 3 1 4 Trout Snook Redfish
$18.00

Recently Purchased Trout Fishing:


sebile magic swimmer sinking 3 3495mm lure 38oz 105g lure, teasers 30 lot of 4 striped bass fluke trout sand eel bend back fly cfishon, teasers 10 lot of 4 striped bass fluke trout sand eel bend back fly cfishon, teasers 20 lot of 4 striped bass fluke trout sand eel bend back fly cfishon, 10 pack vicious strike tamp;a jigs redfish trout snook king jig heads 12 oz, fishing lure trout barra jacks queenfish kingfish sealurer fish 14cm silverb al2, fishing lure trout barra jacks queenfish kingfish sealurer fish 14cm gold al2, fishing lure trout barra jacks queenfish kingfish sealurer fish 14cm green al2, storm kickin stick slow sinking plug bass trout fish fish lure, 10 pack vicious strike tamp;a jigs redfish trout snook king jig heads 316 oz, 10 pack vicious strike tamp;a jigs redfish trout snook king jig heads 18 oz, 10 pack vicious strike tamp;a jigs redfish trout snook king jig heads 516 oz, 10 pack vicious strike tamp;a jigs redfish trout snook king jig heads 38 oz, 10 pack vicious strike tamp;a jigs redfish trout snook king jig heads 14 oz, 20 pack vicious strike tamp;a jigs redfish trout snook king jig heads 14 oz, fishing lure trout barra jacks queenfish kingfish sealurer fish 14cm gold al1, fishing lure trout barra jacks queenfish kingfish sealurer fish 14cm silverb al1, fishing lure trout barra jacks queenfish kingfish sealurer fish 14cm green al1, 6 pack 18oz spinner bait lure hook for ice fishing bass trout salmon crappie, fishing lure trout barra jacks queenfish kingfish sealurer fish 14cm green al4, fishing lure trout barra jacks queenfish kingfish sealurer fish 14cm gold al4, fishing lure trout barra jacks queenfish kingfish sealurer fish 14cm silverb al4, 45cm bream fishing lure perch cod redfin bass yellowbelly trout bream crankbait, 3pcs fishing lure barra jacks salmon tailor trout kingfish bream tuna 12cm, 18cm fishing lures barra trout tuna gt kingfish threadies salmon tailor rainbow, 4cm vibes 4pcs bream bass flathead trout redfin whiting cod perch snapper, 115cm fishing lures bream bass trout redfin salmon tailor barra white rainbow, 145cm fishing lures barra kingfish tailor salmon trout silver black, 9cm fishing lure bream bass flathead trout redfin whiting blue, 145cm fishing lures barra jacks kingfish salmon tailor trout green, 115cm fishing lure barra trout jacks redfin tailor yellowbelly salmon rainbow, 115cm fishing lure barra trout jacks threadies queenfish salmon perch cod, minnow lures 115cm barra jacks trout cod bass redfin salmon tailor pink, motion minnow lure sand trout 55 inch 1oz by mareagear, 6pk 34oz super glow squid diamond fishing striper trout cod lure jig 1605, 6 old trout lures in a lure box, 4pk 6oz fluke grouper snapper trout seabass squid fishing lure jig hook 1756, 3pk 4oz fluke grouper snapper trout seabass squid fishing lure jig 50 hook 1755, 100mm fishing lures trout redfin murray cod yellowbelly bass rainbow swimbait, bream fishing lures 9pcs bass trout redfin perch cod flathead whiting 45mm, 3pcs 60mm fishing lures bream cod redfin barra bass yellowbelly trout fish, 110m trout lures fishing trout redfin cod yellowbelly perch 14g freshwater, 89mm fishing lures bream trout redfin murray cod salmon bass barra, 120mm fishing lures barra jacks threadies trout bream cod yellowbelly fish, 127mm fishing lure barra threadies salmon tailor gold fish trout cod, 76mm bream fishing lures trout redfin bass whiting flathead salmon fish, 36mm fishing lure bream bass flathead trout redfin whiting perch tackle, 12cm fishing lures minnow trout cod redfin barra bass yellowbelly redfin salm, fishing lure wood shrimp squid jigs squid hook minnow trout lure green, fishing lure wood shrimp squid jigs squid hook minnow trout lure blue, fishing lure wood shrimp squid jigs squid hook minnow trout lure orange, rapala xrap jerkbait 4 716oz rainbow trout xr10rt, 4pk 4oz fluke grouper snapper trout seabass squid fishing lure jig hook 1749, 4pk 4oz fluke grouper snapper trout seabass squid fishing lure jig hook 1748, 4pk 4oz fluke grouper snapper trout seabass squid fishing lure jig hook 1747, 4pk 4oz fluke grouper snapper trout seabass squid fishing lure jig hook 1746, 4pk 4oz fluke grouper snapper trout seabass squid fishing lure jig hook 1745